Why Choose Us ?

The Fertility Clinic High Success Rates.fw

The Fertility Clinic Save evidence based treatment

The Fertility Clinic Indvidulised care

The Fertility Clinic One to One support

What is Infertility ?

Success Stories

Success Stories The Fertility Clinic

The Fertility Clinic Google

The $50,000 Daughter

The cost of the "perfect family" is steep, financially and morally.

From the time she was a small girl, Jayne Cornwill wanted to be a mom. That sounds sweet, but wait for the rest of it. She didn’t want to mother just any child. She specifically wanted a little girl.

The Fertility Clinic The 50000 Daughter
She was close to her mother. She dreamed of her own “little mummy’s girl." After her first son was born she “wasn’t too disappointed” because she assumed (rather oddly) that the next child would be a daughter. But after two more boys came, she grew desperate, and she and her husband left their native Australia to travel to California for “gender-selection treatment.”

In a world with in-vitro fertilization, many things are possible. Among them, we can demand (for a price) children of our preferred sex. The concept, at least, is diabolically simple. The mother’s eggs are harvested, fertilized, and grown to the point where the sex can be determined. Embryos of the unwanted sex are then discarded, while a few healthy eggs of the desired sex are transferred to the mother’s womb. The implantation isn’t always successful, so parents must be prepared to spend a substantial sum for their dream child. To obtain their much-desired daughter, the Cornwills went through two rounds of IVF and spent $50,000.

To Catholics, it should be clear that this practice is gravely immoral, most especially because it involves the callous disposal of unwanted babies. The Cornwills were dissatisfied with the children that were naturally born to them. Their solution was to bring into being a whole host of unique, precious children, so as to give themselves the “pick of the litter." The rest of their newly-created offspring were most likely just thrown away.

Even for those who deny the value of immature human lives, Cornwill’s manifesto  (which was intended as an argument for legalizing gender-selection in Australia) should set off multiple alarm bells. Her entire perspective on maternity and family is so obviously unhealthy that no reasonable person could read this as an argument for gratifying her tyrannical demands. Let’s consider a few of the more obviously defective ideas that Cornwill unashamedly sets out in her reflection.

“Ever since I was little,” she relates, ”my only goal in life was to have a daughter, and as an adult that desire only grew stronger. I come from a mixed-gender family with two older brothers and an older sister, and I saw the benefits of growing up with both perspectives. I also think society pushes the idea of the "perfect" family being two parents, with two children — one boy and one girl. I certainly thought so.”

We already know that Cornwill’s idea of a “perfect” family is fanciful to the point of absurdity; she’s admitted that she assumed her second child would be female simply because the first was male. Clearly, that kind of reality avoidance is unhealthy. My attention was arrested, however, by her observation that children are better off “growing up with both perspectives." That is, she thinks it beneficial to have both a male and a female presence within a family.  

I would agree. But mightn’t it be more natural and appropriate to achieve that balance among… the parents? When a family begins with the uniting of man and woman (as has been the near-ubiquitous custom throughout history, until the present day) a complementary male and female “perspective” is established from the very beginning, and it isn’t necessary to impose such inflexible conditions on what sort of children we’re willing to accept. Same-sex marriage isn’t the subject of Cornwill’s piece, but she notably doesn’t mention “mother” and “father” as established elements in her perfect family. She herself has a husband. Even so, one wonders whether gender-selection treatment might, for her and others, be a kind of back-door way of validating the importance of gender complementarity.

“It's hard to explain the heartbreak of "gender disappointment" and how it can consume you. Every gift — every blue babygrow and toy car — was a reminder of the fact my life wasn't going the way I planned.”

“Consumed” certainly seems like the right word for it. Cornwill speaks about becoming deeply depressed, to the point of barely being able to go out. She admits to sobbing in disappointment during her second son’s ultrasound. The third time, she fell into deep depression and considered abortion.

All this time, one cannot but notice the shallowness of her self-examination. Admitting that friends accused her of superficiality and “playing God," she justifies herself mainly with the repeated assertion that her desire was real and intense. No consideration is given to the possibility that a sincere desire may nevertheless be vicious. This is an obvious failure of ethical reasoning. Desire should never in itself be viewed as justificatory, however intense it may be.

Even when the things we want are basically good and wholesome in themselves, they can turn vicious when we elevate personal fulfillment over all other considerations of duty or propriety. That clearly seems to have happened here. It isn’t wrong to want a daughter. But it is wrong to suppose that a child’s life can be justified purely in terms of a grown-up’s desire to experience parenthood, or to experience it in a particular way.

It’s amazing, through all her agonizing about daughters, that Cornwill doesn’t reflect more on whether perhaps it might be her own perspective (and not genetic happenstance) that is defective. God has blessed her with multiple healthy children, but she can’t stop seeing them as accessories meant to fill out a kind of mental tableau of “perfect” family life. It’s distressing to hear of the anguish this has caused her, but far more disturbing to think how her attitudes might be impacting her family.
 
Imagine her sons reading this piece a few years hence. As a mother of three boys myself, I can’t but be appalled at her lack of concern for their feelings. What child wouldn’t be crushed by the discovery that his mother didn’t want him? As heartbreaking as that is, I almost feel more keenly for the cherished daughter, whose life supposedly represents the fulfillment of her mother’s “single life goal." What if she isn’t everything her parents hoped? What if she’s a tomboy and not an affectionate “mummy’s girl”? Can the Cornwills get a refund on their fifty thousand? Accessorizing children in this way can have devastating consequences both for the wanted and for the unwanted.

As I have argued elsewhere, Westerners need to rediscover a more natural, organic understanding of parenthood. Only then will they stop tormenting themselves and their children with selfish and superficial ideas of what it means to be a family.

Source: www.aleteia.org

 

Follow The Fertility Clinic On FacebookFollow The Fertility Clinic On TwitterFollow The Fertility Clinic On Google

Arrange an appointment with us

Contact Jemma Hand to arrange an appointment with one of our fertility specialists.

call the fertility clinic

 

Telephone +44 (0)800 689 1317

Telephone +44 (0)7860 439346
Email admin@thefertilityclinic.org.uk

Fertility Clinics

Liverpool Fertility Clinic
Spire Murrayfield Hospital
Holmwood Drive
Wirral. CH61 1AU

London Fertility Clinic
No10 Harley Street
London. W1G 9PF

Women have trusted The Fertility Clinic

 

Dr Gazvani on City Talk

I can't get pregnant ?

why can i not get pregnant

We Will Tell You ?

 

Read More...

The Fertility Clinic Latest News (2)

  • 1
  • 2
Prev Next

Scientists hail 'amazing discovery' as it's revealed infertile mothers who use donor eggs DO pass their DNA to their children

Infertile women forced to use donor eggs still pass their DNA to their child The 'amazing discovery' was made by scientists at a Spanish fertility clinic Had been thought fertilised egg only...

Read more

Egg Donation a Thriving Business

Pretoria - More and more families affected by fertility problems have turned to egg donations as their preferred option of having children, saying they not only give them the chance...

Read more

We Want a Boy: The Ethics of Sex Selection in the Clinic

Controversy is no rarity in the field of reproductive endocrinology and infertility. Since its discovery and early clinical applications, everyone seemed to have (and still has) an opinion about in...

Read more

Why it’s wrong to ban anonymity for egg and sperm donors

‘Both donors and recipients should be allowed opt for either anonymous or identifiable donation as they see fit. In short, I am for choice’ The central pillar of the Children and...

Read more

The best physicians in the field of infertility and egg donation come to Charleston to discuss high-tech advancements

One of the most important medical conferences in North America focusing on the field of Infertility Medicine is being hosted by Charleston’s own Coastal Fertility Specialists, March 5 – 8...

Read more

Egg Freezing Seminar Allows Women to Pause the Biological Clock for Age, Social or Medical Reasons

Atlanta Center for Reproductive Medicine invites women to attend a discussion and social gathering on March 30 to learn more about egg freezing. Build your family when the time is...

Read more

Couple uses IVF to have baby girl, raising questions on ethics of sex selection

Ever heard of “gender disappointment”? Jayne and Jon Cornwill certainly have. It’s what drove the Australian couple to mortgage their house, fly to California, and cough up nearly $50,000 to...

Read more

Google++ Lets You Select Your Own Gender

Unity in diversity – I suppose that is where the word “university” comes from, where every element is an individual, and yet on the collective whole, it makes up a...

Read more

Sexual ‘rights’? I do not think that word means what you think it means.

When abortion activists came out shrieking with rage at Canadian Member of Parliament Stephen Woodworth’s suggestion that a committee examine human life in the womb in 2013, he was somewhat...

Read more

Gender selection: Australian couple spent $50,000 and travelled to US to have baby girl

Couple sought out gender selection treatment, which is illegal in Australia, after having three boys With three sons already, Jayne Cornwill and her husband Jon were intent on having a baby...

Read more

The $50,000 Daughter

The cost of the "perfect family" is steep, financially and morally. From the time she was a small girl, Jayne Cornwill wanted to be a mom. That sounds sweet, but wait for...

Read more

The Facts About Egg Donation

For a woman who has been through a number of failed IVF cycles, egg donation gives new hope, while for women who are unable to provide eggs for IVF, it...

Read more

Tina Malone - This Morning 7th November 2014

After dropping almost 12 stone, with the aid of a gastric band, in order to receive the IVF treatment she was desperate for, Tina and her husband finally conceived their...

Read more

Designer babies: Should gender selection be legal?

AUSTRALIAN couples are now travelling to the United States to access fertility clinics to choose their unborn baby’s gender. While most couples are satisfied if they give birth to healthy...

Read more

One in 10 fresh IVF cycles use donated egg and sperm

One in 10 fresh IVF cycles use donated egg and sperm

One in 10 fresh IVF cycles used donated fertilised eggs or embryos, and a third of all patients were single or had registered with a female partner, reveal the latest...

Read more

Rapid Fertility Access

The Fertility Clinic Rapid Fertility Access

Lets Get Started

 

Take The Next Step...

Choosing an IVF Centre ?

The Fertility Clinic Spire Murrayfield Hospital Wirral 2

We Will Tell You ?

 

Read More...

The Fertility Clinic Latest News

  • 1
  • 2
Prev Next

Scientists hail 'amazing discovery' as it's revealed infertile mothers who use donor eggs DO pass their DNA to their children

Infertile women forced to use donor eggs still pass their DNA to their child The 'amazing discovery' was made by scientists at a Spanish fertility clinic Had been thought fertilised egg only...

Read more

Egg Donation a Thriving Business

Pretoria - More and more families affected by fertility problems have turned to egg donations as their preferred option of having children, saying they not only give them the chance...

Read more

We Want a Boy: The Ethics of Sex Selection in the Clinic

Controversy is no rarity in the field of reproductive endocrinology and infertility. Since its discovery and early clinical applications, everyone seemed to have (and still has) an opinion about in...

Read more

Why it’s wrong to ban anonymity for egg and sperm donors

‘Both donors and recipients should be allowed opt for either anonymous or identifiable donation as they see fit. In short, I am for choice’ The central pillar of the Children and...

Read more

The best physicians in the field of infertility and egg donation come to Charleston to discuss high-tech advancements

One of the most important medical conferences in North America focusing on the field of Infertility Medicine is being hosted by Charleston’s own Coastal Fertility Specialists, March 5 – 8...

Read more

Egg Freezing Seminar Allows Women to Pause the Biological Clock for Age, Social or Medical Reasons

Atlanta Center for Reproductive Medicine invites women to attend a discussion and social gathering on March 30 to learn more about egg freezing. Build your family when the time is...

Read more

Couple uses IVF to have baby girl, raising questions on ethics of sex selection

Ever heard of “gender disappointment”? Jayne and Jon Cornwill certainly have. It’s what drove the Australian couple to mortgage their house, fly to California, and cough up nearly $50,000 to...

Read more

Google++ Lets You Select Your Own Gender

Unity in diversity – I suppose that is where the word “university” comes from, where every element is an individual, and yet on the collective whole, it makes up a...

Read more

Sexual ‘rights’? I do not think that word means what you think it means.

When abortion activists came out shrieking with rage at Canadian Member of Parliament Stephen Woodworth’s suggestion that a committee examine human life in the womb in 2013, he was somewhat...

Read more

Gender selection: Australian couple spent $50,000 and travelled to US to have baby girl

Couple sought out gender selection treatment, which is illegal in Australia, after having three boys With three sons already, Jayne Cornwill and her husband Jon were intent on having a baby...

Read more

The $50,000 Daughter

The cost of the "perfect family" is steep, financially and morally. From the time she was a small girl, Jayne Cornwill wanted to be a mom. That sounds sweet, but wait for...

Read more

The Facts About Egg Donation

For a woman who has been through a number of failed IVF cycles, egg donation gives new hope, while for women who are unable to provide eggs for IVF, it...

Read more

Tina Malone - This Morning 7th November 2014

After dropping almost 12 stone, with the aid of a gastric band, in order to receive the IVF treatment she was desperate for, Tina and her husband finally conceived their...

Read more

Designer babies: Should gender selection be legal?

AUSTRALIAN couples are now travelling to the United States to access fertility clinics to choose their unborn baby’s gender. While most couples are satisfied if they give birth to healthy...

Read more

One in 10 fresh IVF cycles use donated egg and sperm

One in 10 fresh IVF cycles use donated egg and sperm

One in 10 fresh IVF cycles used donated fertilised eggs or embryos, and a third of all patients were single or had registered with a female partner, reveal the latest...

Read more

TheFertilityClinicLogo2

Abbey Fertility Clinic, 6 Telford Court, Chester, CH1 6LT

London Fertility Clinic - No10 Harley Street, London, W1G 9PF

Telephone : +44 (0)800 689 1317 Mobile : +44 (0)7860 439346

Follow The Fertility Clinic On FacebookFollow The Fertility Clinic On TwitterFollow The Fertility Clinic On Google

 

crown logo small

 

Copyright © 2014. The Fertility Clinic All Rights Reserved.